Jessica Davis is the youngest of the four sisters competing in the 2012 Extreme Mustang Makeover in Madison, WI. Davis took home first prize in the Idols division of her first mustang challenge in 2009 with her mount Rock'N Red. This is her fourth mustang, but her first mare. Davis and Kat placed 9th out of 31 trainers.
Sandi Jankowski is the oldest of the sisters. She encouraged Davis to participate in her first mustang makeover. Jankowski is a professional photographer and amateur western rider. She bred and trained her current competitive mount and has ridden many unbroken horses in her youth. This is her second mustang, whose personality is vastly different from Jankowski's last mustang.
Nancy Koller is a stay-at-home mom and amateur dressage rider. This is her third mustang to be made over. Koller kept her first mustang, Captain Barbosa, and now uses him as her dressage mount.
Jaci Wenz is the middle sister. She is a riding instructor, and professional horse-breaker. She has started colts for Canadian Team rider, Karen Cudmore. This is Wenz's second mustang makeover and first female mustang. She and Dolce placed 13th out of 31 trainers.